Home -> Magazines -> Issues -> Articles in this issue -> View
On The Cards | |
Sound card featureArticle from Music Technology, April 1994 |
There's a revolution going on in the high street. People with no musical experience can now write and record songs. All you require is a PC, a sound card... and MT's definitive guide. Ian Waugh is your dealer.
The explosion in the soundcard market has given many computer users the opportunity to get involved in serious music-making for the first time. For others it's been the source of frustration as they struggled to get their CPUs to talk to a new system extension. For those looking to buy a sound card, there is also confusion over which card to choose and what kind of quality to expect. Here with help for one and all is Ian Waugh...
Connectivity - that's the name of the game. Impressive as they may be, modern computers can't do everything. Not without a bit of help. PCs and Apple Macs, for example, contain internal slots capable of taking an enormous range of plugin cards to help them perform other functions.
The PC is the most expandable of all computers, and cards available include modems (for communicating with other computers), scanner cards, and maths cards (for speeding up mathematical calculations). Most PCs already have some slots taken up with a card to control their hard disk and a video display card which produces the picture you see on the monitor.
There is also a wide range of cards to interest musicians and people working in multimedia. Video capture cards (not to be confused with video display cards) let you store video clips on disk for editing. And, of course, there are sound cards. These started life as a means of adding synthesised sounds to the PC (which otherwise only has a paltry single-sound beep), primarily for games, but they have now developed into veritable jacks-of-all-trades with facilities such as digital recording and playback, and also interfacing for MIDI and CD-ROM players. Some use quite sophisticated forms of synthesis and are capable of high-quality digital recording.
Apple Macs have card slots, too. The most well-known is the NuBus slot, but the LC family have PDS slots which, though taking up less space, work in a similar way. These are used for coprocessors to speed up maths functions, graphics cards for special video displays and networking cards for connecting the Mac to other Macs or a PC. Most of the Mac sound cards are used for digital recording. As far as I am aware there are currently no Mac cards containing sounds (other than Sample Cell II which is more akin to a sampler), but please put me right on this one if there are.
As with most things Mac, you can usually plug a card into your computer, boot your application and start using it. As with all things PC, plugging in cards isn't likely to be as straightforward...
PCs have 8-bit and 16-bit card slots. You can easily see which is which because 16-bit slots are longer than 8-bit ones (most PCs with 16-bit slots also have at least one 8-bit slot) and there is a small gap between the rows of connectors. You can use most 8-bit cards in a 16-bit slot quite happily. Stereo sound cards and cards with 16-bit sampling resolution will be 16-bit cards.
But plugging the card in is the easy bit. You then have to configure it. Depending on the card's facilities this could involve you in port addresses, DMA and IRQ settings. It's all part of the process of telling the computer exactly where the sound card is in relation to the system and it could be argued that this simply reflects the PC's flexibility, but it's a flexibility that can lead you into problems - problems which the Mac user doesn't have to worry about as everything is taken care of automatically.
If you don't have any other devices in your PC, you may be able to simply plug in and go. However, like as not you'll have to change at least some of these settings. The better software supplied with the cards lets you test the system and make changes through the program - although if there is a conflict (that is, if another card is using the same IRQ or DMA channel), it's not always easy to track down. Settings can also usually be changed on the card itself using DIP switches or by changing the position of jumper pins.
When you've got that working you then have to install some drivers to control the card. There will be different drivers for DOS and Windows applications. Usually installation is fairly easy although this depends on the installation routines supplied. The ethos behind Windows means that an application does not have to know exactly what is connected to the system. It simply talks to the driver and the driver sends the necessary instructions to the hardware. Windows comes with several drivers which you can see in the Drivers section of the Control Panel.
There are two main PC sound-card standards, both named after the cards that started the trend. The Ad Lib card was taken as the standard for music and most sound cards support this. The Sound Blaster added digital audio and the ability to play back sampled speech and sound effects. It's also backwards compatible with the Ad Lib card and unless your budget is limited, Sound Blaster compatibility should be your aim. But sound-card technology moves on and more sophisticated standards are starting to appear. Sound Blaster Pro offers 20-voice stereo sound and many games now have this as an option. Look for Pro compatibility if you're serious about your games.
The other emerging standard is GM (General MIDI) and some cards contain a set of GM sounds which can be particularly useful for the muso on a budget - GM and digital recording in one package.
But given that most of these cards cost well under £200, just what kind of audio quality are we talking about here? Well, this is where the cracks begin to show. Most of the cheaper cards use the Yamaha YM3812, a 2-operator FM chip, which may be adequate for games but it would hardly pass muster even at a karaoke night. Cards with the Yamaha OPL3 chip are noticeably better although it's still FM and well below current state-of-the-art sound synthesis. Still, it is GM-compatible and that must earn it a few extra brownie points.
If you want sounds more in keeping with today's standards then you need to look at wavetable synthesis cards such as the Orchid Soundwave 32, the Gravis Ultrasound and the Wave Blaster add-on as well as the Roland SCC-1 and the Turtle Beach cards. The Multisound card, for example, contains the equivalent of a Proteus 1/XR synth!
Digital audio, again, was originally developed for games and based around 8-bit sampling but the development of stereo 16-bit cards supporting sample rates up to 44.1 KHz raised the quality, certainly to that of good demo standards. If you compare these with dedicated digital audio systems it must be remembered that sound cards are called upon to do several tasks while digital audio systems are designed to do one job well and usually include additional hardware to do it. Dedicated systems will have superior digital converters so the sound quality is bound to be better.
As with most things, you get what you pay for, but if you are on a budget sound cards really are worth considering.
Where most of the cards fall down is the recording software which is not as sophisticated as dedicated software such as Turtle Beach's Wave for Windows, Voyetra's Audio View or Innovative's SAW. Still, you can often use this software with a card of your choice. SAW, for example (watch out for a review in MT very soon), is compatible with the Sound Blaster ASP.
If you want to move more upmarket, there are several dedicated digital audio cards to choose from for both the PC and the Mac. PC cards such as the CardD+ and the Turtle Beach cards are still very affordable and capable of producing excellent results.
8-bit PC cards | |||||
Card | Price | Supplier | Emulations | Sample rate (kHz) | Comment |
Sound Commander EX | £46.00 | Comsol Systems | AL/SB | 44.1/44.1 | Joystick and MIDI ports; pack includes speakers. |
Orchid Sound Producer | £49.00 | Orchid | AL/SB | 22/22 | Includes mini speakers; unpretentious. |
Orchid Sound Producer Pro | £89.00 | Orchid | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Stereo version of Orchid's Sound Producer using two 8-bit digital/audio converters; includes a Panasonic CD-ROM interface with SCSI as an option. |
Sound Blaster 2 Deluxe | £65.00 | Westpoint Creative | AL/SB | 44.1/15 | The card the rest are modelled on; it may not have all the tinsel but for maximum compatibility, this is the one. |
Super Sound Two Plus | £75.00 | Gallant | N/A | 50/50 | Includes Sony and Panasonic CD ROM interface (Mitsumi available as an option); manual poor. |
ATI Stereo FX | £79.00 | Metrocom | AL/SB | 15/15 | Highly compatible; includes 8W amp for headphones or a small speaker (not supplied). |
Sound Galaxy NX Pro Extra | £92.83 | Silica | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Includes Panasonic and Mitsumi CD-ROM interface (Sony optional); mic and mini speakers; configurable from software; good quality sound. |
Sound Blaster Pro Deluxe | £99.00 | Westpoint Creative | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Sound Blaster compatibility in true stereo; 20 voices; includes Panasonic CD-ROM interface and lots of software. |
Gallant SC5000 | £125.00 | Gallant | AL/SB/SBP/GM | 50/50 | Mini speakers and hand-held mic included; Panasonic and Sony CD-ROM interfaces (Mitsumi as an option). |
16-bit PC cards | |||||
Card | Price | Supplier | Emulations | Sample rate (kHz) | Comment |
Media Vision Pro Audio Spectrum 16 | £139.00 | Ingram Micro | AL/SB/SBP/GM | 44.1/44.1 | Mitsumi and Panasonic CD-ROM interfaces plus SCSI. |
Sound Galaxy NX Pro 16 Extra | £151.58 | Silica | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Includes a mic and headphones; Panasonic and Mitsumi CD-ROM interfaces (Sony optional); SCSI optional - software configurable/upgradable to 16-bit wavetable synthesis with Wave Power (£116.33) card. |
Advanced Gravis Ultrasound | £199.00 | Optech | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/44.1 | 16-bit playback, 8-bit recording (16-bit recording is optional); CD-ROM interface optional; excellent wavetable sounds; interesting 3D surround sound effect. |
Logitech SoundMan 16 | £199.00 | Logitech | AL/SB | 44.1 /44.1 | A Media Vision Pro Audio 16 (the basic version) clone; easy installation; no CD-ROM interface. |
Microsoft Sound System | £120.00 | Microsoft | AL | 48/48 | More for business than games or music; no Sound Blaster emulation (although a new version will have this); no CD-ROM interface or joystick port; bundled with a Mic and business-oriented software including voice recognition. |
Orchid Soundwave 32 | £199.00 | Orchid | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/44.1 | Uses wavetable synthesis - good sounds; compatible with the Roland MT-32 and Microsoft Sound System; includes speakers; Sony and Mitsumi CD-ROM interfaces. |
Orchid Gamewave 32 | £175.00 | Orchid | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/NA | Similar to the Orchid Soundwave but no recording ability or Sound System emulation; no speakers and comes with less software. |
Sound FX 16-Bit | £99.00 | Bluepoint | AL/SB | 48/48 | Similar to Sound FX Classic 3000 (see below) but without wavetable synthesis; bundled with 2020 Sound Editor and Sound Impression; addition of Wave FX board (£125) effectively turns it into a Classic 3000 (Wave FX package includes Cubase Lite and MIDI cable). |
Sound FX Classic 3000 | £199.00 | Bluepoint | AL/SB/GM/GS | 48/48 | Unique to date in having a GS emulation (although it has no reverb); includes MIDI adaptoOr lead; bundled with Cubase Lite and Sound Impression; supports Sony, Panasonic and Mitsumi CD-ROM interfaces; digital sound quality very good. |
Sound Blaster Pro 16 ASP | £219.00 | Westpoint Creative | AL/SB/SBP/GM | 44/44 | The current top-of-the-range Sound Blaster; ASP (Advanced Signal Processor) improves digital audio speed and includes data compression; Panasonic CD-ROM interface; includes a mic and voice recognition software, a simple animation program and a CD multimedia encyclopedia; FM sound (an OPL3 chip) may be improved by adding a Wave Blaster board. |
Cyber Audio Card | £249.00 | Unica | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/44.1 | Wavetable synthesis offers good sounds; compatibility problems with certain software; includes a SCSI interface and comes with a microphone headset and voice recognition software. |
SCC-1 | £430.00 | Roland | AL/SB/GM | N/A | A Sound Canvas on a card but with none of the recording facilities or extras you expect to find on a games or multimedia card; excellent sound. |
PC digital audio cards | |||
Card | Price | Supplier | Comment |
Roland ATW-10 | £449.00 | Roland | Package includes the RAP-10 sound card (not available separately) and some excellent, highly graphic edit and arranging software; lets you combine CD tracks, digital audio and MIDI files. (See review in MT February '94). |
Digital Audio Labs' CardD | £757.00 | Digital Music | Highly-specified card; software offers 2-track stereo recording at rates up to 48KHz; non-destructive editing and customised fades MIDITasker will trigger sound files via MIDI for audio/MIDI integration; optional I/O card provides S/PDIF support. |
Kalix SoundTrax | £499.00 | Digital Music | Records at rates up to 48KHz; includes Ensoniq GM sounds (based on the ASR-10); MPU-401 MIDI interface, four internal DSPs, support for Sony CD ROM and SCSI-2; RAMStore lets you create your own sounds from WAV samples; Ad Lib and Sound Blaster compatible. |
Maui | £198.00 | Et Cetera | GM-compatible sound card; 24 voices (wavetable synthesis); SampleStore lets you download samples into the card to create your own sounds; MIDI interface is MPU-401 compatible. |
Multisound | £468.00 | Et Cetera | High-quality 16-bit 44.1 KHz recording plus 384 sounds based on the E-mu Proteus; Advanced Hurricane Architecture works up to eight times faster than DMA techniques; GM-compatible. |
Tahiti | £351.00 | Et Cetera | As the Multisound card but without the Proteus synthesiser. |
Macintosh digital audio cards | |||
Card | Price | Supplier | Comment |
Audiomedia II | £1202.00 | Digidesign | Plugs into NuBus slot and offers high-quality stereo 16-bit recording up to 48KHz; analogue Ins and Outs plus S/PDIF; SoundDesigner II software features non-destructive playlist editing plus effects such as compression, pitch shifting, EQ and dynamics; supported by major direct-to-disk software such as Studio Vision, Cubase Audio and Notator Logic Audio. |
Audiomedia LC | £908.00 | Digidesign | Similar to Audiomedia II but uses the LC-type PDS slot; no S/PDIF interface; maximum rate of 44.1 KHz. |
Sample Cell II | £1822.00 | Digidesign | 16-bit sample player on a NuBus card; eight polyphonic Outs; expandable up to 32Mb RAM; 32 dynamically-assigned voices; over 20 CD-ROM libraries of sounds available. |
BeeBMIDI Monitor (Part 1) |
Technically Speaking (Part 1) |
Digital Signal Processing - An introduction (Part 1) |
Apple Notes |
Software Support - Hints, Tips & News From The World Of Music Software |
PC Notes |
MIDI and the Micro |
How To Become An Atari ST Power User - Hardware (Part 1) |
Macro Music (Part 1) |
PC Notes |
Computers in Music - A Cheaper Option? |
Optical: Illusion Or Reality? - Optical Media Explained |
Browse by Topic:
Feature by Ian Waugh
mu:zines is the result of thousands of hours of effort, and will require many thousands more going forward to reach our goals of getting all this content online.
If you value this resource, you can support this project - it really helps!
New issues that have been donated or scanned for us this month.
All donations and support are gratefully appreciated - thank you.
Do you have any of these magazine issues?
If so, and you can donate, lend or scan them to help complete our archive, please get in touch via the Contribute page - thanks!
8-bit PC cards | |||||
Card | Price | Supplier | Emulations | Sample rate (kHz) | Comment |
Sound Commander EX | £46.00 | Comsol Systems | AL/SB | 44.1/44.1 | Joystick and MIDI ports; pack includes speakers. |
Orchid Sound Producer | £49.00 | Orchid | AL/SB | 22/22 | Includes mini speakers; unpretentious. |
Orchid Sound Producer Pro | £89.00 | Orchid | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Stereo version of Orchid's Sound Producer using two 8-bit digital/audio converters; includes a Panasonic CD-ROM interface with SCSI as an option. |
Sound Blaster 2 Deluxe | £65.00 | Westpoint Creative | AL/SB | 44.1/15 | The card the rest are modelled on; it may not have all the tinsel but for maximum compatibility, this is the one. |
Super Sound Two Plus | £75.00 | Gallant | N/A | 50/50 | Includes Sony and Panasonic CD ROM interface (Mitsumi available as an option); manual poor. |
ATI Stereo FX | £79.00 | Metrocom | AL/SB | 15/15 | Highly compatible; includes 8W amp for headphones or a small speaker (not supplied). |
Sound Galaxy NX Pro Extra | £92.83 | Silica | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Includes Panasonic and Mitsumi CD-ROM interface (Sony optional); mic and mini speakers; configurable from software; good quality sound. |
Sound Blaster Pro Deluxe | £99.00 | Westpoint Creative | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Sound Blaster compatibility in true stereo; 20 voices; includes Panasonic CD-ROM interface and lots of software. |
Gallant SC5000 | £125.00 | Gallant | AL/SB/SBP/GM | 50/50 | Mini speakers and hand-held mic included; Panasonic and Sony CD-ROM interfaces (Mitsumi as an option). |
16-bit PC cards | |||||
Card | Price | Supplier | Emulations | Sample rate (kHz) | Comment |
Media Vision Pro Audio Spectrum 16 | £139.00 | Ingram Micro | AL/SB/SBP/GM | 44.1/44.1 | Mitsumi and Panasonic CD-ROM interfaces plus SCSI. |
Sound Galaxy NX Pro 16 Extra | £151.58 | Silica | AL/SB/SBP | 44.1/44.1 | Includes a mic and headphones; Panasonic and Mitsumi CD-ROM interfaces (Sony optional); SCSI optional - software configurable/upgradable to 16-bit wavetable synthesis with Wave Power (£116.33) card. |
Advanced Gravis Ultrasound | £199.00 | Optech | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/44.1 | 16-bit playback, 8-bit recording (16-bit recording is optional); CD-ROM interface optional; excellent wavetable sounds; interesting 3D surround sound effect. |
Logitech SoundMan 16 | £199.00 | Logitech | AL/SB | 44.1 /44.1 | A Media Vision Pro Audio 16 (the basic version) clone; easy installation; no CD-ROM interface. |
Microsoft Sound System | £120.00 | Microsoft | AL | 48/48 | More for business than games or music; no Sound Blaster emulation (although a new version will have this); no CD-ROM interface or joystick port; bundled with a Mic and business-oriented software including voice recognition. |
Orchid Soundwave 32 | £199.00 | Orchid | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/44.1 | Uses wavetable synthesis - good sounds; compatible with the Roland MT-32 and Microsoft Sound System; includes speakers; Sony and Mitsumi CD-ROM interfaces. |
Orchid Gamewave 32 | £175.00 | Orchid | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/NA | Similar to the Orchid Soundwave but no recording ability or Sound System emulation; no speakers and comes with less software. |
Sound FX 16-Bit | £99.00 | Bluepoint | AL/SB | 48/48 | Similar to Sound FX Classic 3000 (see below) but without wavetable synthesis; bundled with 2020 Sound Editor and Sound Impression; addition of Wave FX board (£125) effectively turns it into a Classic 3000 (Wave FX package includes Cubase Lite and MIDI cable). |
Sound FX Classic 3000 | £199.00 | Bluepoint | AL/SB/GM/GS | 48/48 | Unique to date in having a GS emulation (although it has no reverb); includes MIDI adaptoOr lead; bundled with Cubase Lite and Sound Impression; supports Sony, Panasonic and Mitsumi CD-ROM interfaces; digital sound quality very good. |
Sound Blaster Pro 16 ASP | £219.00 | Westpoint Creative | AL/SB/SBP/GM | 44/44 | The current top-of-the-range Sound Blaster; ASP (Advanced Signal Processor) improves digital audio speed and includes data compression; Panasonic CD-ROM interface; includes a mic and voice recognition software, a simple animation program and a CD multimedia encyclopedia; FM sound (an OPL3 chip) may be improved by adding a Wave Blaster board. |
Cyber Audio Card | £249.00 | Unica | AL/SB/GM | 44.1/44.1 | Wavetable synthesis offers good sounds; compatibility problems with certain software; includes a SCSI interface and comes with a microphone headset and voice recognition software. |
SCC-1 | £430.00 | Roland | AL/SB/GM | N/A | A Sound Canvas on a card but with none of the recording facilities or extras you expect to find on a games or multimedia card; excellent sound. |
PC digital audio cards | |||
Card | Price | Supplier | Comment |
Roland ATW-10 | £449.00 | Roland | Package includes the RAP-10 sound card (not available separately) and some excellent, highly graphic edit and arranging software; lets you combine CD tracks, digital audio and MIDI files. (See review in MT February '94). |
Digital Audio Labs' CardD | £757.00 | Digital Music | Highly-specified card; software offers 2-track stereo recording at rates up to 48KHz; non-destructive editing and customised fades MIDITasker will trigger sound files via MIDI for audio/MIDI integration; optional I/O card provides S/PDIF support. |
Kalix SoundTrax | £499.00 | Digital Music | Records at rates up to 48KHz; includes Ensoniq GM sounds (based on the ASR-10); MPU-401 MIDI interface, four internal DSPs, support for Sony CD ROM and SCSI-2; RAMStore lets you create your own sounds from WAV samples; Ad Lib and Sound Blaster compatible. |
Maui | £198.00 | Et Cetera | GM-compatible sound card; 24 voices (wavetable synthesis); SampleStore lets you download samples into the card to create your own sounds; MIDI interface is MPU-401 compatible. |
Multisound | £468.00 | Et Cetera | High-quality 16-bit 44.1 KHz recording plus 384 sounds based on the E-mu Proteus; Advanced Hurricane Architecture works up to eight times faster than DMA techniques; GM-compatible. |
Tahiti | £351.00 | Et Cetera | As the Multisound card but without the Proteus synthesiser. |
Macintosh digital audio cards | |||
Card | Price | Supplier | Comment |
Audiomedia II | £1202.00 | Digidesign | Plugs into NuBus slot and offers high-quality stereo 16-bit recording up to 48KHz; analogue Ins and Outs plus S/PDIF; SoundDesigner II software features non-destructive playlist editing plus effects such as compression, pitch shifting, EQ and dynamics; supported by major direct-to-disk software such as Studio Vision, Cubase Audio and Notator Logic Audio. |
Audiomedia LC | £908.00 | Digidesign | Similar to Audiomedia II but uses the LC-type PDS slot; no S/PDIF interface; maximum rate of 44.1 KHz. |
Sample Cell II | £1822.00 | Digidesign | 16-bit sample player on a NuBus card; eight polyphonic Outs; expandable up to 32Mb RAM; 32 dynamically-assigned voices; over 20 CD-ROM libraries of sounds available. |
BeeBMIDI Monitor (Part 1) |
Technically Speaking (Part 1) |
Digital Signal Processing - An introduction (Part 1) |
Apple Notes |
Software Support - Hints, Tips & News From The World Of Music Software |
PC Notes |
MIDI and the Micro |
How To Become An Atari ST Power User - Hardware (Part 1) |
Macro Music (Part 1) |
PC Notes |
Computers in Music - A Cheaper Option? |
Optical: Illusion Or Reality? - Optical Media Explained |
Browse by Topic: