Magazine Archive

Home -> Magazines -> Issues -> Articles in this issue -> View

Right As Rane

Rane Mojo Series

Article from Sound On Stage, November 1996


Rane's new Mojo range aims to combine excellence of design with operational simplicity and affordable pricing. PAUL WHITE tests the MX 23 Divider, the MQ 302 Filters, and the MC 22 Squeeze.


Rane's Mojo series is the company's first serious attempt to produce a budget range of products aimed at semi-pro musicians, but instead of saving money by cutting corners on quality, they've opted instead to leave out unnecessary features. The core circuitry and components have much in common with their pro counterparts, but the front panels provide the bare minimum of what's needed to get the job done.

With the exception of a headphone amplifier (not reviewed here), the Mojo range is specifically aimed at the semi-pro live sound market where it is envisaged that the simplified operation will be viewed as a benefit rather than a limitation.

On review are the MX 23 stereo electronic crossover, the MQ 302 graphic equaliser, and the MC 22 dual channel compressor/limiter. All include novel design features, and in the case of the crossover, some aspects of its performance rival far more expensive crossovers due to an ingenious new approach to circuit design.

MX 23 stereo three-way electronic crossover.


MX 23 STEREO THREE-WAY ELECTRONIC CROSSOVER



There are two electronic crossovers in the Mojo range, but as the only difference between them is the number of bands, we've decided to concentrate on the three-band MX 23. As you might surmise, the MX 22 is a two-band version, which is correspondingly cheaper at £349.

Specifying crossovers for a professional touring rig is quite a complicated procedure where an experienced audio engineer needs to consider the frequency ranges, roll-off characteristics, and sensitivities of the speaker cabinets before deciding on the crossover frequencies, filter slopes, and filter characteristics. The setting must then be verified using a real-time analyser.

The gigging band with their own system is unlikely to have the expertise or test equipment to make the necessary measurements or to meaningfully interpret the results, so Rane have come up with a much simplified crossover that has a single control to vary the crossover point between each band and a level control for each band. In the case of the MX 23, that means a total of just five front panel controls for a stereo system, but to give their product that extra bit of flexibility, there's also a mono feed on the rear panel with a switchable 100Hz low-pass filter that can be used to drive a single-channel sub-woofer system.

The filter slopes and characteristics are fixed (24dB/octave, Linkwitz-Riley), so all the user has to do is to adjust the frequency at each crossover point, then adjust the level of each band to get an acceptably even sound.

A conventional stereo crossover would require frequency control pots with four closely matched resistive elements — any departure from perfect matching would mean an unwanted change in the filter characteristics at the crossover point. Matched four-section pots are very expensive, so Rane have instead used a single pot to control a set of matched VCAs, which form part of the tunable state-variable filters. The result is near-perfect tracking, and because 24dB/octave filters are used, there's no unwanted phase shift and very little overlap between frequency bands.

Housed in a mains powered, 1U rack case, the MX 23 has balanced ins and outs on XLRs driven by the same high quality balancing circuit used in Rane's pro range of processors. The Mono Sub output has its own XLR socket, recessed level preset, and a slide switch to operate the 100Hz filter. This output contains a mix of the left and right Low outputs, but for use with a sub-woofer, the 100Hz low-pass filter should be switched in. This doesn't affect the feed to the main crossover outputs, it just ensures that little above 100Hz makes it to the sub-woofer.

Because the front panel controls are stereo ganged, there's no way to get a mismatch between the left and right channel settings. The only criticism I have of this otherwise excellent product is that there seems to be no way to lock the frequency controls against accidental movement once they are properly set. In all other respects, the unit works exactly as specified with more than enough tuning range to accommodate any sensible combination of speaker cabinets.

Rane's approach to the MX 22 and MX 23 means that the gigging band can afford a really high quality crossover that is as simple to set up as it is possible for an electronic crossover to be. The inclusion of Rane's high end balanced circuitry and a useful mono sub-woofer feed combined with very precise filtering and tough engineering makes this a very serious and flexible performer that should stand up to intensive touring with no problems. I'd be inclined to put it in a rack with some sort of cover over the controls to prevent tampering, but apart from that, it's ready to go and is very sensibly priced.

At this point, it's worth mentioning that the manual, although concise, contains some excellent advice on setting up crossovers; it also covers both balanced and unbalanced connections in authoritative detail. To the inexperienced user, this information is an absolute necessity.

MQ 302 third-octave stereo graphic equaliser.


MQ 302 THIRD-OCTAVE STEREO GRAPHIC EQUALISER



Rane were the first company to promote the idea of a graphic equaliser with constant Q filters, and their pro units have an enviable reputation in both live sound and recording studios. In live sound, graphic equalisers are indispensable for compensating for room acoustic problems and for notching out troublesome frequencies that threaten to cause feedback. Unfortunately, budget graphics often suffer, because adjustments in one band can affect the next band along. This is known as interband interaction, and one of the benefits of constant Q, as opposed to proportional Q (where the filter Q changes depending on how much cut or boost is applied), is that inter-band interaction is kept to a minimum.

Rane figured that they couldn't cut costs by simplifying the circuitry, but they could switch to using stereo faders so that the same fader controls both left and right channels. This not only saves on parts costs, it also means that stereo mixes are easier to control with no possibility of the left channel being set up differently to the right channel. The MQ 302 is, in all other respects, a straightforward device with both XLR and jack electronically balanced inputs and a choice of outputs on both balanced XLRs and unbalanced jacks. The unbalanced output has its own driver circuit, which means that it can be used at the same time as the balanced output, if there's a need to split the signal. What's more, the provision of an unbalanced output means that there is no level loss when connecting to an unbalanced piece of equipment, as would usually be the case when unbalancing a balanced output. There is a single input level control (but regrettably no overload LED), a single bypass button, and 30 short-travel faders, each providing up to 12dB of cut or boost. There is no external power supply — a captive means lead feeds a low-noise toroidal transformer, and the audio circuitry provides a very respectable 115dB dynamic range.



"... one of the benefits of constant Q... is that inter-band interaction is kept to a minimum."


The faders, which have a lovely smooth, positive feel, are centre detented and very clearly labelled. They are also divided into three groups, presumably for ease of construction, but this also makes it easier to identify the frequency band you want to work on.

In use, the MQ 302 is a very clean, musical sounding equaliser that doesn't seem to introduce the tonal fuzziness or phasiness that cheaper designs sometimes do. The overall effect is best described as positive, and because the controls set both channels simultaneously, setting up takes only half the time. Indeed, there are so many applications for a stereo graphic equaliser that I imagine this model will find its way into keyboard rigs and recording studios as well as PA rigs. You can still buy cheaper graphic equalisers, but this one is a truly professional performer.

MC 22 dual channel compressor/limiter.


MC 22 DUAL CHANNEL COMPRESSOR/LIMITER



The MC 22 has undergone a great deal of simplification in terms of its control interface, but you still get a very sophisticated compressor behind the front panel. Indeed, not only do you get a variable ratio, progressive knee compressor, you also get a completely automatic expander which acts almost like a gate, cleaning up the output when no signal is present. What's more remarkable is that all this is accomplished using just three knobs per channel — and one of those deals with the input level.

Like the graphic EQ, the 1U MC 22 is mains powered and features balanced inputs on both XLRs and jacks. The outputs are on both balanced XLRs and unbalanced jacks. There is no side-chain access, but you can tie both channels for true stereo operation using the Link switch. Each channel has its own Bypass button — although no bypass LEDs, which could be confusing in poor light. In stereo link mode, the compressor seems to take an average of both right and left-hand channel settings, so it makes sense to set the two channels to as near the same settings as possible.

Unusually, the MC 22 doesn't have an output make-up gain control, but instead has an Input Level pot which should be set so that the +4dBu LED flashes (but with the overload LED remaining off). This brings the signal up to the optimum level for the compressor circuit and also ensures that the expander will come into play at signal levels of around -55dB. Whenever the expander is active, the ADX LED comes on to show that 2:1 expansion is taking place.

Setting the compressor is simply a matter of choosing a ratio, then turning the Threshold knob until the 5-section LED gain reduction meter shows a suitable reading. Although the Ratio control only covers the range 1:1 to 10:1, the progressive knee nature of the compressor circuit means that if the input signal tries to push too far past the threshold setting, the compression ratio rises automatically to a higher figure than that indicated by the control. Because of this useful characteristic, when using higher compression ratios, excess levels are eventually subjected to limiting, hence the compressor/limiter title.

There are no controls for attack and release times — Rane did a lot of research to find out what setting experienced engineers tended to use and then built these into the MC 22. The figures arrived at were 30ms/10dB for the attack and 0.3dB/ms for the release.

Despite its simplicity, the MC 22 does the job of regulating signal levels very positively and controls are a positive bonus, and it's very difficult to get this little box to misbehave. On a subjective level, I'd say the sound is quite assertive, and you can usually tell that compression is taking place, but in quite a benign, almost flattering way. The expander comes in quite transparently at about the right level, and although some experienced engineers are likely to bemoan the loss of a separate expander threshold control, the inexperienced user has a lot less to worry about. In some ways, I'd have liked to have seen the traditional make-up gain control on the output, but other than that, and the lack of bypass status LEDS, there's nothing to complain about.

All in all, the MX 23 Divider, MQ 203 Filters, and the MC 22 Squeeze appear to bode well for the future success of the complete Mojo Range.

pros & cons

RANE MX 23 £449

pros
- Excellent build quality.
- Simple controls with additional mono sub-bass feed.
- Good technical performance.

cons
- No simple way to lock the frequency controls once set.

summary
This is a first class active crossover for those who want a straightforward, easy-to-use unit with an impeccable technical spec.

pros & cons

RANE MQ 302 £449

pros
- Excellent build quality.
- Smooth fader control with clear markings.
- Good sonic performance.

cons
- No overload LED.

summary
This is an ideal graphic equaliser for processing any stereo signal whether for front-of-house PA, stage monitoring, keyboards, stereo bass guitar rigs, or recording studios.

pros & cons

RANE MC 22 £349

pros
- Excellent build quality.
- Incredibly simple controls.
- Performs well over a wide range of programme material.

cons
- No make-up gain control or bypass LEDs.

summary
A wonderfully simple, yet effective compressor for both mono and stereo applications.

info

MX 23 £449; MQ 203 £449; MC 22 £349. All prices include VAT.

Shuttlesound, (Contact Details).


SETTING UP

Any active crossover must be set up so that each speaker cabinet is fed frequencies only within its operating range, and also so that the system as a whole has a flat frequency response. You do need to have some information about the frequency range of your speakers to set up a system properly (available from the manufacturer's data sheets or handbooks), but so long as you know the usable range of each speaker cabinet in your system and set the crossover frequencies somewhere in the middle of the overlap regions, there are a couple of simple ways to set the level controls. First comes the quick and dirty method, but if you have good ears, there's no reason not to get good results.

The problem with testing a PA system indoors is that room reflections will significantly affect the frequency response. If at all possible, you should test the system outdoors where there are no strong reflections, and if you have no test equipment at all, then play music through the system from a CD player and fine tune the crossover points and levels by ear. At this point, you can either mark the control settings and never change them, or, as some people prefer to do, you can use the crossover level controls to tweak the PA response to match each venue. Used in this way, the crossover behaves almost like a three-band graphic EQ.

A more accurate way to set up the system, based on Rane's own directions, is to use a pink noise source (such as is available on the Sound Check test CD available from mail order) in conjunction with a sound level meter. Although you can always hire a sound level meter, a budget model from a store such as Tandy should be good enough. After deciding on the crossover frequencies (again, you have to set these somewhere in the overlap region between the frequency ranges of your various cabinets), feed pink noise through the system with just the bass amplifier switched on and all the crossover levels turned down.

Next, turn the crossover input level all the way up and position the sound level meter around 15 feet from the stack, well above ground and in a stable position where it won't be moved. Now, increase the level of the Low crossover level control until you get a 0dB reading on the meter. If the meter has a switchable response time, switch it to slow, and set the Weighting switch to C. Be sure to make your measurements when outside noise from other sources is at a minimum.

Now switch off the bass power amp, turn on the mid power amp, and increase the Mid level control until the meter again reads 0dB. Finally, turn off the mid power amp, turn on the high frequency power amp, and repeat the procedure. The idea is that when fed with a pink noise source, your system should produce the same meter reading from each speaker cabinet, indicating that the system is producing a nominally flat frequency response. Now, with all the power amplifiers switched on, you can audition some music and make fine adjustments to the crossover frequencies by ear if need be. Listen particularly for the way changing the crossover frequencies affects the sound of vocals and choose a setting (still within the overlap range of the drivers) that gives the best subjective vocal sound.


WHY USE ACTIVE CROSSOVERS?

Active crossovers split the audio signal into two or more bands before it reaches the power amplifiers, and although this means you need separate power amplifiers to drive each frequency band (usually bass, mid, and top), there are significant advantages over systems that use conventional passive crossovers. Because active filtering occurs before the signal is amplified, you don't lose any power in the crossover circuit. With a passive system, power has to be, in effect, wasted to get the most sensitive speakers to match up in level with the least sensitive ones, but using an active system, you simply feed the less sensitive speakers more power to increase the overall level. Also important is that the filter response of an active crossover can be much more precisely controlled, reducing the unwanted overlap between bands.

Because each band is fed from a separate power amplifier, if a loud transient causes clipping at the bass end, it won't have any effect on the mid or high frequencies, whereas with a passive system, any clipping affects all bands and could damage your high frequency units. In practical terms, active systems are generally louder, clearer, and less prone to damage from overdriving than their passive counterparts, although exactly the same loudspeakers may be used. The bass end also tends to be better controlled and tighter sounding.

We'll be taking a more detailed look at crossovers and multi-way loudspeaker systems later in our 'Practical PA' series.


WHAT GOES WHERE

In a system driven from an electronic crossover, such as the MX 22 or MX 23, the graphic equaliser would normally come directly before the crossover and the compressor/limiter directly before the equaliser. The same arrangement could be used for the stage monitor system.

Where it is desirable to compress a single instrument or microphone rather than the entire mix, the compressor should be patched into the relevant channel insert point on the mixer. Conversely, mono or stereo subgroups may be compressed by patching the compressor into the subgroup insert points. For stereo applications, the Link switch on the compressor should be turned on.

Graphic equalisers may also be patched in via insert points where it is required to affect the tonality only of specific instruments or subgroups of instruments. To use a graphic equaliser with an instrument rig, it should either be connected to the amplifier's effects loop or connected between the preamplifier and power amplifier.


IMPLICATIONS OF COMPRESSION

For those who have no previous experience of compressors, one thing to be aware of is that compressors are simply automatic level controls — when the signal level exceeds the threshold, the circuit turns the level down a bit, just as a human engineer might pull down a fader. This means that if you want your loudest signals to be at the same level as they were before they were compressed — and let's say you have the compressor set to apply 10dB of gain reduction to the highest peaks — then you're going to have to add 10dB more gain on your mixer. This, in turn, means that when the signal input is lower than the threshold (ie. uncompressed), the system gain is going to be 10dB higher than normal — which brings you 10dB closer to feedback. In practice, this means that when working live, you have to use as little compression as you can get away with — in other words, don't set the threshold for more gain reduction than you really need — in situations where feedback might be a problem. Vocals are the obvious example of feedback prone mics, but miked acoustic instruments such as acoustic guitars are equally problematic.

You don't have to worry so without undue side-effects unless you use more gain reduction than is necessary, in which case you can hear the onset of gain pumping. Indeed, because few people are very confident about setting up complicated compressors, the simple much if you're compressing a miked electric guitar or bass, because then you already have a lot of level, so there'll be a lot less gain on those mics than on the vocal mics.

Another application for a compressor is to put it across the entire mix with the ratio turned fully up, and with the threshold set so that gain reduction only occurs when your power amplifiers get close to clipping. In this way, your MC 22 acts as a safety limiter to prevent your PA system overloading during the more enthusiastic moments of the performance. Not only does this avoid distortion, it can also help protect speakers, especially tweeters, from damage.



Previous Article in this issue

Blackpool Rock

Next article in this issue

Live in Concert


Publisher: Sound On Stage - SOS Publications Ltd.
The contents of this magazine are re-published here with the kind permission of SOS Publications Ltd.


The current copyright owner/s of this content may differ from the originally published copyright notice.
More details on copyright ownership...

 

Sound On Stage - Nov 1996

Donated & scanned by: Mike Gorman

Review by Paul White

Previous article in this issue:

> Blackpool Rock

Next article in this issue:

> Live in Concert


Help Support The Things You Love

mu:zines is the result of thousands of hours of effort, and will require many thousands more going forward to reach our goals of getting all this content online.

If you value this resource, you can support this project - it really helps!

Donations for May 2024
Issues donated this month: 0

New issues that have been donated or scanned for us this month.

Funds donated this month: £0.00

All donations and support are gratefully appreciated - thank you.


Magazines Needed - Can You Help?

Do you have any of these magazine issues?

> See all issues we need

If so, and you can donate, lend or scan them to help complete our archive, please get in touch via the Contribute page - thanks!

If you're enjoying the site, please consider supporting me to help build this archive...

...with a one time Donation, or a recurring Donation of just £2 a month. It really helps - thank you!
muzines_logo_02

Small Print

Terms of usePrivacy