Home -> Magazines -> Issues -> Articles in this issue -> View
Infinite World | |
Michael BrookArticle from Music Technology, October 1992 | |
By a babbling Brook
Low-tech guitar and hi-tech synths and sequence dovetail perfectly on guitarist, composer and producer Michael Brook's latest album, Cobalt Blue, which sees him drawing on diverse musical traditions to make music which sounds at once timeless and contemporary.


Brook has been using C-Lab software for almost three and a half years now, starting out with Creator and subsequently switching to Notator when a record he was working on needed printouts for string parts - though he never uses the notation side of the software himself. Currently he's thinking of switching to Cubase on the Mac.
"I like the linear aspect of Cubase," he says, "although the Mac version of Notator looks like it's going to be more linear. I suppose I want to try and get away from looped things, and it seems like Creator really encourages you to work with short loops. Having said that, it's good software, and I think the timing of it is very good, rhythmically, with all the groove stuff. I didn't use that stuff on the record because I didn't know about it then, but I like it more and more now, it can really loosen up a sequence. But there again, if you're combining sequenced and live percussion and live guitar then in some ways it's okay if you have these rigid things underpinning it. They don't sound too mechanical, and in fact maybe they help the whole thing sound stronger.
"People's expectations of timing have really been affected by machines a lot. You listen to some of those great old records - like I was listening to Sly Stone and JJ Cale recently and the timing is all over the place. Nowadays it would be rejected but in fact it's just exciting. When tempo changes happen through incompetence that's one thing, but when they happen through the natural inhalation/exhalation of the music... I think it's a huge expressive factor that's been lost, something that was an integral part of music until seven or eight years ago, when all of a sudden it was forbidden because the machines couldn't do it and the fact that people could was viewed as a sort of human frailty."
Nowadays, of course, sequencers have become more flexible in dealing with tempo fluctuations, with tempo maps allowing continuous changes to be programmed as part of a sequence. For his production work on the soon-to-be-released debut album by British songwriting duo Balloon, Brook developed what he refers to as a 'closest approximation' technique.
"First there was a rigid click, and the two guys would play along but also try and pull it the way they wanted it to go," he explains. "I would make tempo changes in the sequencer to try and keep the click in with the way they were pulling it and then they would play to that tempo track and I would make further tempo changes to follow them, until it felt comfortable. And it worked, really quite well. There was a big difference in the songs with and without the tempo changes."
In addition to his own infinite guitar electronics, Brook makes use of IVL's Pitchrider pitch-to-MIDI system to trigger the TX802 from his Tokai guitar. However, he has mixed feelings about the value of controlling MIDI instruments from a guitar: "It's really good for giving you access to different timbres on the guitar, or maybe to more than one sound at a time, but it limits your playing technique. You sort of have to wear a straitjacket to play it because you have to be so precise. Also, on the low strings the timing just isn't good enough. But it does open a couple of doors that you couldn't open any other way. Like, there's one live piece I do where I have a radically different tuning, with octaves between strings. I actually want to explore different tunings a bit more with it. This one isn't even made any more, though; they just couldn't find a big enough market for it."
In contrast, Brook's infinite guitar electronics allow him to make the most of the nuances of guitar technique. He developed the Infinite Guitar in the early eighties after seeing fellow guitarist Bill Nelson using an E-bow to get the same sort of effect. When his own order for an E-bow kept getting mislaid he developed the Infinite Guitar to do the same job.
Currently there are only two other guitars in the world customised with Brook's electronics; one is owned by U2's The Edge and the other by Daniel Lanois. Brook hopes that his Infinite Guitar might be manufactured commercially one day, so understandably he's not too specific about the electronics involved, but essentially what happens is that the strings are made to oscillate continuously by feeding the output signal back into the guitar. Because the sound doesn't decay, changes in pitch can be produced simply by moving a finger up and down a string.
"For me it's been great 'cos it allows me to do a lot of the Middle-Eastern or Indian-sounding melodies by bending the strings," says Brook. In fact, he's even had a scalloped fretboard fitted to give his fingers more purchase on the strings for this very purpose. With a filter pedal in the feedback loop, Brook can switch instantly between normal and infinite guitar and make the infinite guitar sound cross over into harmonics. "It's not totally controllable," he points out. "In fact, it's quite organic."
For live work, Brook uses a Roland MC50 sequencer in place of his Atari and Notator setup. He transfers his sequences into the MC50 by playing them across via MIDI rather than by saving them as Standard MIDI Files and loading them in off disk.
"I find that because each sequencer is structured differently it never works to transfer sequences as files," he maintains. "I used to use a Yamaha QX sequencer that used macros - which were kind of loops - and then I put stuff from that into the C-Lab, which uses patterns. But you couldn't transfer to the Roland; with the macros you could have different length patterns repeating - but not in the Roland. You have to make everything into one big sequence, which means you have to rearrange. So it's easier just to record from one sequencer into the other."
Has Brook found the MC50 to be reliable in a live situation?
"It's been totally reliable. You just put the disk in, hold down a button, turn it on and it loads up your whole show. It's great - I like it."
However, Brook does have his own horror story about using digital technology live.
"I was doing a concert with Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan in Italy and I'd made up some new sequences for it," he recalls. "They worked here, but when we got to Italy the notes wouldn't trigger reliably. I use long MIDI notes, like a four-bar note, to trigger the Bel delay and these would trigger three times, four times and then stop. And yet my old disks from my solo concerts worked fine and the same material in Notator worked fine. I came back to England and the MC50 worked fine.
In fact, I don't actually know that I would blame the Roland for the problem, because only the Bel was having trouble - nothing else. The only thing I can think of was something marginal like the fact that the mains is 220 volts there but 240 here. Or maybe it was interference; I think because digital technology is logical we expect it to be consistent, but it's subject to interference just as much as other things. I think good electronic designers acknowledge that even with digital technology there are almost organic interactions that happen. The thickness of wires, how close components are - all sorts of things affect it that make it more like art than science."
In recent years, Brook's career as a producer has been blossoming, with albums by Youssou N'Dour, Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan and Cheb Khaled to his credit. His production of Youssou N'Dour's Set came about after Peter Gabriel introduced him to N'Dour's manager.
"When I saw Youssou and his band play live, I thought it was better than anything they had got on record at that time," he recalls. "Youssou live was alive, he just had this amazing fire and power in his voice that I hadn't heard on record that much. I thought that maybe he'd felt kind of tense in studios before, so I wanted to bring in a sense of gestalt into the studio as much as we could.
"That's why I wanted to bring the dancer in, so that they would feel comfortable and then maybe the tape would capture them playing and feeling comfortable. So, allowing them to play was important, but also working on the arrangements and getting a little more dynamics into the music than they had live - not just in terms of loudness but also in timbre and colour. I felt the musical sophistication was already there, what I wanted to have was a sonic sophistication that complemented what was happening in the music."
Talking about sonic sophistication, would he agree that the synth patches used in, for instance, Algerian rai music often sound rather 'cheesy' and unsophisticated to Western ears.
"I think part of that is the technological time lag," says Brook, "but also... Youssou's keyboard player was into more sophisticated sounds, but for Khaled's- stuff it wasn't a high priority. Hi-fi is no big deal for them, they just care about the ornamentation and the way the song goes. In fact, they're often surprised by our fixation on the nuance of a sound because for them it's all in the playing. I think a lot of the synth sounds selected are the ones that come close to timbres used in their traditional music. Arabic sounds are often quite mid-range-y and nasal sounding and we associate that with slight cheesiness, but for them it's just the sound of the real instruments that they have around them."
With Pakistani singer Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan, Brook tried "...to bring the power and grace of Nusrat's singing into a Western setting because he'd already done dozens and dozens of traditional records. A few people were pissed off, saying it was a profanity against the sacredness of his music to use Western rock 'n' roll elements. But it wasn't at all. This was trying to get a collaboration between Nusrat and sympathetic Western musicians."
Upcoming projects include music for a documentary on the firefighters of Kuwait, and a collaboration with Joe Bogart of Technotronic. And, as Brook explains, he's keen to get more involved with other musicians...
"I'm tired of the bedroom studio type of situation," he opines. "I think with the next record I'd like to try working with an actual band. You can sort of disappear into your own navel a little bit with MIDI and sequencers and stuff - although, working in a very solitary way can be a good thing. I guess I'm getting hungry for the interaction between different personalities. Musicians are an amazing bargain, really. You can spend days just screwing around with one little part, trying to make it work, and maybe you will, but... with things you've done yourself, you can't really separate the fact of your investment in it; if you spend three days trying to get something, then you end up thinking 'Well, it must be good'. But if somebody comes in who doesn't know how things have gone, that you sweated blood over something, they can just say 'Well, that part doesn't work.'
"Also, you can just get somebody in for an afternoon who... they're a different person, different background, different ideas, and they just put this sort of slash of a new colour across what you're doing. Roger did that. He was here for about three days, and he would just put these things on top that I in a million years would never think of - and he contributed a huge amount because of that, I think."

Pedals:
ElectroHarmonix 16-second Delay
E-H Memoryman Analogue Delay
Sansamp Amp Simulator
Korg OVD1 Overdrive
Yamaha GE10M Graphic HQ
DOD Compressor
Hot Tubes Fuzz
Ernie Ball Volume Pedals (x6)
Rack Effects:
Bel BD80S Sampling Delay
Drawmer M500 Compressor
Dulay 16 second Delay Line (custom-built)
Eventide H3000 Harmoniser
Lexicon LXP1 Reverb
Yamaha SPX90 Multi-effects Processor
Vocal Effects Waveform Animator (self-built)
Instruments:
Roland R8M Drum Module
Roland S770 Sampler with Sony optical disk storage unit
Simmons Portakit
Yamaha DX7 Synth
Yamaha TX802 Synth Module
Yamaha TX816 Synth Module
Recording:
Allen & Heath Sabre 24:16:2 Mixing Desk
Atari 1040ST Computer running C-Lab Notator software
Digital Music MX8 MIDI Patchbay
Fostex E16 Multitrack
Panasonic 3700 DAT Machine
Rauch Amp
Sony DTC1000 DAT Machine
Yamaha MCS2 MIDI Control Station
Yamaha NS1000 Monitors
Live Setup:

Bel BD80S Sampling Delay
Digital Music MX8 MIDI Patchbay
Drawmer M500 Compressor
Eventide H3000 Harmoniser
IVL 7000 Mk2 Pitchrider pitch to MIDI converter
Lexicon LXP1 Reverb
Neve 1073 Pre-amp (used with guitar)
Roland MC50 Sequencer
Seck 18:8:2 Mixing Desk
Simmons SPX 8:2 Rack-mount Mixer
Tokai Guitar and pedals (see above)
Yamaha MCS2 MIDI Control Station
Yamaha SPX90 Multi-effects Processor
Yamaha TX802 Synth Module
In The Mood (Michael Brook) |
Beyond The Infinite (Michael Brook) |
Michael Brook - Canada Dry (Michael Brook) |
The Life Of Brian (Brian Eno) (Part 1) |
The Life Of Brian (Brian Eno) (Part 2) |
U2 - can have an Edge like this (The Edge) |
Relatively Speaking (Roger Eno) |
Edgeways (The Edge) |
Eno Sense (Brian Eno) |
Brian Eno - Breaking The Silence (Brian Eno) |
Roger Eno - The Composer's Tale (Roger Eno) |
Discretion (Brian Eno) |
from Jams to James (Brian Eno) |
Interview by Simon Trask
mu:zines is the result of thousands of hours of effort, and will require many thousands more going forward to reach our goals of getting all this content online.
If you value this resource, you can support this project - it really helps!
New issues that have been donated or scanned for us this month.
All donations and support are gratefully appreciated - thank you.
Do you have any of these magazine issues?
If so, and you can donate, lend or scan them to help complete our archive, please get in touch via the Contribute page - thanks!