We Are The Management
Who are the music biz' management, and do you really need them? David Bradwell talks to the people who take care of the stars and their affairs.
You're in the market for a record contract so you're going to need a manager, right? But even the record industry seems confused about what makes a good manager.
"There is a constant battle of wits with record companies, contracts change all the time and you always need to keep fully aware of what is going on."
THE RECORD COMPANY side of the story gives a slightly different perspective on the importance of good management. While the general consensus of opinion is that managers are helpful, most agree that they are not strictly necessary, and in some cases can prove a hindrance. Daniel Miller - head of Britain's most successful independent record company, Mute - believes that if you haven't got a record deal, a manager can help secure a good one.
"Up until recently none of our acts had a manager", Miller explains, "they all worked directly with the record company. Sometimes it is helpful to have another person to refer to, although it's good that record companies and bands can have a good relationship by themselves. A good tour manager who takes no artistic decisions takes some of the pressure off. Depeche Mode manage themselves, although they employ three people - two to look after tours and one to handle the fan club. I used to be put off by managers because I wanted to deal directly with the bands, but now, depending on the nature of the group, I prefer a manager. This is partly because we have grown as a company, to the extent that personal contact with bands has become increasingly difficult.
"Bad managers are worse than no managers at all; a good manager needs to be able to motivate. It is important for producers and engineers to have a contact point outside the studio, because there's nothing worse than being in the middle of a mix and being interrupted by someone ringing up to confirm the next project."
While it would seem that the larger the company the greater is the need for a manager, EMI's Paul Morgan doesn't agree. Formerly with Atlantic, Morgan joined the EMI A&R department just over two years ago. He believes that management isn't too important even up to the stage of signing the much-coveted deal.
"You can get that far just by dealing with a lawyer", he explains. "Management companies themselves refer to lawyers anyway, so there's no difference in that respect. It's not necessarily true that a known manager is going to have more success than a new one. If, for example, a well known, good rap manager has a new rap act, he will be paid attention. But if he is venturing into a new area of music, his reputation is fairly irrelevant because he is working with different media and different contacts.
"Pressure from managers can backfire on them. If a manager pressurises me, I will go to the head of A&R and the chances are he will react back just as strongly. Good managers should know who to talk to, how, why and when. Managers are most useful in their relationship with the marketing department, deciding on the best campaign strategies for new releases."
Mute offshoot Rhythm King is a record company which effectively manages its own artists. Combining the roles of management and record company works well due to the relatively small scale of the company, and only causes problems when they are approached by bands who have managers of their own. Martin Heath is in charge of signing new talent at the label, and is fluent in expressing his views.
"I think the most important thing is that managers have faith in their artists. A lot of them just do it because they think they can get some money and fame. They are totally ignorant about the business and think it's an easy way to make money - which it isn't.
"For us the use of managers is limited, because we tend to refer all of our decisions to our artists anyway. When a band is starting out, management is very important to motivate them, to get them to point where they are signed to a record company and to inform the record company of what the band are about. They have to ensure the band get what they want up to limits and ensure they don't alienate the record company in the process, which is a delicate game. You can't spot good managers until you work with them and that's really why we don't like dealing with them.
"Our relationship with our bands is very important to us, and without that a lot of us lose our motivation. There can be a big power dilemma where a manager knows a lot about the band but nothing about the record business, and at the same time, the A&R man doesn't really know that much about the band. It's in the interaction between those relationships that careers are made or not, as the case may be. People like Tom Watkins who does Bros is the sort of manager who is a visionary, deciding what his bands are going to be like and how the public will perceive them. With Bros, he has entirely manipulated the situation and controls it to the extent that he is probably more important than they are."
Heath believes he is in a position to give bands creative direction in their careers, but recognises that if there's a manager who believes he has the same rights there is a chance of conflict.
"It's not fair to say to somebody who may have been with a band for three years that you're not very interested in their opinions any more", he begins. "That's not to say they don't have good ideas and they can't help you and stimulate you, but there's a difference between that and telling them that the control is in their hands and you are going to do what they want. And that's a big problem. Intelligent managers tend to understand those divisions of labour and maybe get more involved in the promotion of the act overseas. For our purposes, a manager who organises an artist as a personal manager would, and who organises the live side of things and checks up on the foreign licensees is someone of real use.
"The best advice I can give is that if you have a manager, don't listen to how much he bullshits, because that is completely irrelevant. Unless the guy has got a very good, strong track record, everything he says is going to be promises. If you approach a good company and want a good deal, bullshitters are entirely unimpressive, because they see more of those people than anything else. If a manager is prepared to work for a band and he has some access to capital he should be prepared to invest it. The manager can go onto another band, but the artist has generally only got three to five years in the limelight to earn a living. That is the best way of sorting out the bullshitters from somebody who genuinely believes in something. I don't mean masses of money, just enough to pay for occasional things like the demo tapes. It's very easy for bands to believe the hype, but what they should look for in the first instance is some real solid back-up."
"Contracts only tend to be referred to in times of crisis. When things are going well they just sit in the drawer and no-one looks at them."
Heath is well positioned to discuss the problems of being stuck with a bad manager. Expanding on Daniel Miller's comment that bad managers are worse than no managers at all, he outlines some of the effects this can have.
"The problem is the dangerous power games managers play between artists and record companies. The one thing that a manager has got to overcome is the assumption that he's got to fight the record company all the way. That's stupid and it just creates a bad feeling. Most A&R men get so pissed off with aggressive managers that they cease to deal with them. They don't freeze them out, but that band will become relegated in the A&R men's eyes. The band think 'What a wonderful guy, he's so aggressive and hard, everything we're not' but they don't understand that half of the time that can be very damaging.
"Clever managers are people who inspire record companies to think and to work, and who record companies actually like. Bad management is a complete disaster area, and has been the death of more bands than I can name. The truth is, there are extremely few good managers; there are fewer good managers than good bands.
"Somebody who comes in here and bangs his hand on the desk and talks about how the artwork is one thing and the sleeves are another is missing the entire point of Rhythm King as a record company, and really would be the reason why I wouldn't sign a band. There are lots of stories of major record companies having managers in their offices, liking a band but hating a manager and deciding that they're unworkable for that reason."
ASSUMING YOU CAN afford to lose the 10-20% of your earnings that a decent manager will charge, the biggest hurdle is in actually finding one. Anthea Norman-Taylor recommends not approaching an established company, instead finding a trustworthy friend with business experience, and some free time on their hands. Trust seems to be the key word, because you are literally placing your career in the hands of someone else.
Rob Holden explains his views on the best way of approaching Massive Management.
"To be honest, it's by prayer! We always listen to whatever gets sent in - I always promised myself that I would listen to everything, but it becomes very difficult. If we think a band is good, we give the tape to the art department so they can give it a listen. In return, artists should look for enthusiasm from prospective managers. It doesn't matter if they are insurance salesmen, although it helps if they've got some interest in music.
"The easiest band to work with is one with very good ideas of what they want to sound like and how they want to look. The more self-sufficient they are the better. To get a record deal, you have to motivate the record company and get them to like you. Record companies respect us because they know we've been successful, and if we take a tape to them they take notice of it. However, they can be intimidated by big-name managers because they know we're not going to be cheap."
World's End very rarely approach anyone directly. In the last 15 months they have added eight names to their books, mainly via word of mouth from other producers. The same approach is adopted by Vanda Rawlins.
"A lot of it has to be word of mouth", she begins. "I think it's good to talk to people who have been managed by that person, but to do that you have to have a foot in the door anyway. If you're interested in being managed by somebody, look at the kind of people that they manage and see whether you fit into that, and examine their success rate - not necessarily chart success if it's a more independent creative thing. I think it's very important to get on well with the person because it's a very personalised service, especially with a record producer where it's just one person as opposed to a band.
"A lot of bands do mass mail-outs from the addresses in the Music Week directory, and every manager I know will have tapes and CVs of the same band. That's certainly not the best way of approaching it. I expect the people I manage to be professional. I'm not interested in getting work for someone who will blow it by turning up late or being off their face on drugs. I'm prepared to put up with a lot of grief from record companies but I don't expect to get grief from people I manage. I expect us to operate as a team which is what, essentially, we are."
It's difficult to draw conclusions, as so much depends on each individual case. One thing is certain, the man who approaches you in a pub offering wads of cash in exchange for a percentage of your earnings is not the Santa Claus he first appears. Before committing yourself to a management contract you have to decide how committed you are to being successful. A good manager will want as much from you as you require from him or her. Professionalism breeds professionalism, and if you haven't got it to begin with, you certainly won't get it in return. On the other hand, there's no big secret to managing people. There's no one key rule to guarantee success and no single ingredient which makes a great manager. Managers need a certain amount of business sense, but ultimately it is a personal service. The danger is that while a manager can advise you whether or not to sign a record deal, there are very few who can advise about management contracts. A simple, honest approach seems to be the one practised by Vanda Rawlins.
"When you first meet someone you may like them, but you don't know if you'll actually like working together. Generally I would have a basic letter of agreement and work without a contract for the first few weeks. I'm always very wary of someone who instantly waves contracts under your nose. Contracts only tend to be referred to in times of crisis. When things are going well they just sit in the drawer and no-one looks at them."
Ultimately, if you find a good one, with plenty of creative ideas, sharp awareness and a trustworthy nature, a manager can help you to become successful. Securing a contract with a good manager can be as hard as signing one with a good record company, which means we're back to square one. As I think someone once said, "That's rock 'n' roll..."
Feature by David Bradwell
mu:zines is the result of thousands of hours of effort, and will require many thousands more going forward to reach our goals of getting all this content online.
If you value this resource, you can support this project - it really helps!