Performance Signal Processor
Now that multi-effects processors are all the rage, Korg go one better by producing a unit which allows you to add extra effects via ROM cards. Vic Lennard discovers the advantages of open-ended signal processing.
Korg's new multi-effects processor incorporates a fresh approach to defeating obsolescence - the ability to load new effects programs from ROM cards.
IT SEEMS INCREDIBLE to think that Yamaha's SPX90 only appeared on the market some four years ago - and in doing so, opened the door for the multi-effects unit. Most manufacturers have followed suit in the ensuing time, to the point where 16-bit, 18kHz bandwidth units are commonplace, as is the ability to chain together four or more effects at the same time.
Unfortunately, as with MIDI synths, we've seen the demise of the knob, and the simple, immediate form of control it affords. Also, the configuration of multi-effects units - the order in which the effects are chained together - is often limited to a handful of options, with the notable exception of the Yamaha SPX900/1000 series.
Korg appear to have sat back and looked at the field, with the intention of ensuring that the criticisms which have been leveled at the competition will not be directed at their A3.
ENCASED IN A black 1U-high, 19' rack-mount case, the A3 has one of the better front panel layouts, with the visual side taken care of by a 40-character back-lit LCD screen, input bar meter, patch number and status LEDs. What makes this unit special is the seven twin function controls sitting beneath the display. These appear to be rotary knobs but also act as push buttons, whose functions depend on the mode in which the A3 is being operated.
Audio input and headphone levels are dealt with by conventional knobs, and each has a dedicated front-panel jack socket with the one for input overriding that on the rear panel. A bank of six keys for editing and general manipulation complete the front end. The rear has mono jack sockets for audio input, direct audio out, right and left stereo outs and two footswitches along with MIDI In, Out and Thru, and a remote control socket. Input level can be matched with connected equipment via a +4/-20dB switch.
THERE ARE 41 effects onboard the A3 as standard. Of these, six can be used at any one time, subject to the 20 preset chains, or effect connection patterns, which exist for each of 100 memory patches. This is like having 100 sets of 20 footpedals, each with different settings. The effects fall into certain groupings, each of which have suitable parameters. The most significant of these have been picked out below.
The A3's control parameters break down as follows: Reverb group offers two each of Room, Hall and Plate reverb groups having decay times of up to five seconds, pre-delay, high frequency damping, EQ (two-band); Distortion (four types, with drive and a single-band parametric EQ with contour "Q" shape); Delay has three separate groups - Mono, Stereo (including cross-pan) and Modulation, each of which have delay time and feedback, with the latter having LEO controls; Modulation has two each of Chorus and Flange, the difference being the type of LFO generator (sine wave/triangle) with similar controls to the previous group; Early Reflection is essentially gated reverb, again with two-band EQ; Speaker Simulation attempts to copy the driving of a loudspeaker and has three different types with emphasis presets for mid and high; Pan moves the signal between the stereo outputs and Phaser uses phase inversion of the signal with two types of each, again dependent on the choice of LFO. The final effects only have a single type with settings normally attributable to the particular effect - Compressor, Parametric EQ (two-band with Q), Pitch Shift (PL/MI 1 semitone), Exciter, Ensemble (strong choral effect), Rotary Speaker, 3-band EQ (no Q), Pedal Pan and Wah via the volume pedal and Gate).
THE UNIT POWERS up in Individual Play mode, the display showing the chain number along with the name of the patch and the possible effects for the chain. For instance, chain 5 has Compressor, Distortion, Exciter, Delay, Phaser and Reverb in that order, with each effect having one of the six rotaries (labelled A to F) situated beneath it. Pressing any of these buttons turns the effect off and changes the letters from upper to lower case. Twisting these knobs allows selection from the effects within the particular group - In this case, turning the Reverb select knob will select from the six different types of reverb setting. The seventh knob is used to bypass all effects (by pressing it), at which point the LED lights up, or to select which of the 20 chains is being used (by rotating it). To change the patch, there are a pair of key cursors which will increment or decrement the patch number and show the chain which was on display when that patch was saved.
Pressing the Display Select key changes modes, from Individual to Performance. Each effect group has one parameter which has been judged to be the most important, and the display changes from the name of the effect to the name of this parameter as Display Select is toggled. Continuing with our example, Distortion can have the drive altered while Reverb can have the effect balance altered. The only problem here is that there is no visual indication of what the value of the parameter was or has been changed to. Nevertheless, the chosen parameters certainly make editing quick.
"ROM cards can be used to load in new effects in chains and programs - properly supported, it could be a long time before the A3 is out of date."
A push on the Parameter Edit key prompts the name of the patch to change to Select. Dial up the required chain by using the extra rotary and press any of the effects. This brings up the next page on the display, with the allocated editing parameters and a letter on the left-hand side of the screen showing which effect has been selected. If the Reverb is chosen, an F and the parameter's reverb time, high frequency damping, pre-delay, low and high EQ and effect balance appear in the display. Rotating any of the knobs will immediately change the associated parameter, but instead of changing from the previous value, movement of the knob causes the parameter to jump to the current value indicated by the knob. About two seconds after the edit, the display will revert to the name of the parameter. Again this is quick to use but will probably entail the use of pencil and paper to write down the initial settings before editing starts. Of course, there is another way: press Display Select and all current values will be shown in place of the parameter name, making it possible to continuously toggle between the two displays. This tends to be rather tedious until you commit the names and positions of the parameters to memory.
One gripe that I have is that the actual parameter value is of little real significance in many cases. For instance, the attack on the Compressor can take a value between 0 and 20 - however, this does not appear to be time-based. Similarly, the high-frequency damping factor which appears on many of the effects can vary between 0 and 99, but again isn't time- or ratio-based. This means that instant setting up of a parameter by its numerical value is difficult.
Utility mode is used for both patch and global parameters. Name and overall gain for a patch can be set, as well as the threshold control for the inbuilt noise reduction system, which is a preset noise gate. The two rear controller sockets can be told their true purpose in life with the choice of program up/down, bypass or the speed of the rotary speaker in the case of a footswitch, and volume and parameter setting if a continuous pedal is used. The other two functions, MIDI and Card, will be covered later.
Finally, Write mode allows you to save your edited patch. For some reason, there is no write protect facility on the A3, which I would have expected bearing in mind the degree of programming possible - you have been warned.
THE BOTTOM LINE for any effect unit is its sound quality, and the A3 is impressive in this respect. In fact, having compared it with a Yamaha SPX1000 I found it very difficult to tell the difference. Perhaps, as Yamaha own Korg, this isn't surprising, but the microprocessors doing the work are apparently slightly different. Any concern over only having a mono input is dispelled immediately upon hearing, or "seeing", the stereo image. Personally, I have never been impressed with units which boast stereo inputs unless the two channels can be used independently. The A3 has the advantage that as a stereo effect always comes before the reverb, more "spread" to the sound is created, and this spacious quality shows itself in many of the patches.
Looking at individual effects and their uses, the reverbs are practically grain-free and have a more than adequate set of parameters. The stereo delay group deserves a special mention, especially the cross delay which has its input fed from the other channel's delay output. This occurs in chain 6 with ensemble and reverb following it, and the flashing delays create a really dynamic effect. Similarly in chain 10, the stereo delay is fed via a pitch changer, modulation and pan to create a fat ping-pong effect which can then be cross delayed and finished by passing through a reverb.
With distortion, speaker simulation and pedal wah, it would be reasonable to expect to be able to get a good guitar sound. Chain 8 has all three of these as well as EQ, modulated delay and reverb, and really kicks out an American lead guitar sound. Distortion appears to have the drive set at halfway on all patches (I prefer to see it set to 11). The performance parameter for distortion just happens to be... drive. Nicely thought out in that respect.
Quite a few of the chains have the distortion preceded by the compressor, and this combination is guaranteed to give noise with a capital N. The noise gate is necessary to disguise the noise generated, but care has to be taken when assigning a value to this in the Utility page, otherwise the output "chatters" if the noise level hovers around the threshold which has been set. Use of the compressor makes this setting rather difficult to get right.
"The mixture of rotary and push button control is sheer genius and makes me wonder why other manufacturers have made us put up with less."
The exciter really doesn't have the cut expected from such an effect, and seems to be no more than an extra equaliser of sorts - anyone that has spent time working with a real exciter will appreciate the difference. The parametric equaliser has only a single Q control for the two bands that it can work over, which certainly compromises its use. The low band starts at 100Hz which means that any mains-borne hum cannot be removed. The 3-band equaliser has the same low and mid band as the parametric and a high band whose top response is identical to that of the mid band - 8kHz, which is really too low. Neither of these really offer sufficient control over the equalisation of an effect.
Finally, it is worth mentioning that accidental creation of distortion is a little too easy for my liking. It comes about because many of the effects have gain controls and the increase in overall gain doesn't show up on the input meter - there really should be a separate meter for output.
WITHOUT GOING INTO too much detail, the optional FC6 has two modes; the first allows you to change programs, while the second allows you to turn individual effects on and off as an alternative to using the push buttons on the front panel. It has four jack sockets on the rear for connecting two switches and two pedals; the former are for switching between the modes of the FC6 and operating the bypass switch on the A3, while the latter are used for volume and individual effect parameters, which can be set from the Utility page on the A3. This certainly opens up the scope of the A3 for live work, especially on the effects loop from an amplifier or via the auxiliaries on a mixing desk.
WHEN THE LIKES of the Alesis Quadraverb has the ability to address eight parameters per patch via MIDI, it seems fair to expect that some degree of MIDI control would be forthcoming on the A3. Unfortunately it would appear that this technology has yet to reach Korg as, according to the MIDI information and Implementation chart, no parameters can be addressed via MIDI. However, page 30 of the manual mentions that the speed of the rotary speaker can be changed in real time by using an external MIDI instrument and "Transmitting data through MIDI over the same program number as being currently used by the A3". I'm not quite sure what that's supposed to mean, because data transference takes place over a MIDI channel, not a program number. Hopefully Korg will enlighten us as to the true meaning of this in due course.
With respect to what can be done via MIDI, an internal bulk dump can be initiated from the Utility page and the data transmitted to a sequencer. It would appear that a single patch dump has not been implemented, even by an external command. This is a shame as it would make the A3 easier to use from a real-time mixing point of view, as would the ability to change parameters over MIDI. Transferring from memory to card and vice versa, and program changes are the only other MIDI functions catered for.
AS YOU MIGHT expect, RAM cards are available for the saving of all the internal data, namely patches 1-100. These are written to card as 101 to 200 and can then be loaded back into the A3. It would appear that only an entire memory dump is possible, but as I didn't have access to a card, I couldn't check. ROM cards can be used to load in new effects in chains and programs which could be most interesting. Imagine, perhaps a full blown harmoniser or a sampler... The possibilities are limitless and, if this unit is properly supported, it could be a long time before it is out of date, as it can ride on the wave with technology.
THE KORG A3 is a high-quality unit built with flexibility and ease of use in mind. The mixture of rotary and push button control is sheer genius and makes me wonder why other manufacturers have made us put up with less. The inevitable noise build-up when using six effects is satisfactorily masked by the internal noise gate, and the promise of new effects and chains being available via ROM cards is most reassuring.
At £899, how much better is the A3 than the ubiquitous Quadraverb? More effects perhaps, but not a substantially better sound quality. The criteria for choice then comes down to whether the extra effects are what you require.
Price £899 including VAT
Review by Vic Lennard
Previous article in this issue:
Next article in this issue:
mu:zines is the result of thousands of hours of effort, and will require many thousands more going forward to reach our goals of getting all this content online.
If you value this resource, you can support this project - it really helps!